For a small retail store, Square usually wins when most sales happen in the shop: it costs nothing to start, takes 2.6% plus 15 cents in person, and needs no monthly plan. Shopify POS usually wins when online sales matter, because one system runs the shop, the website, and stock. Choose by where most of your sales happen.

Both systems look similar in a demo: a tablet on the counter, card payments, printed receipts. The real differences show up later, in the monthly bill — the percentage taken on every card sale, the monthly fee for the full POS app, what the hardware costs to replace, and how hard it is to leave. This guide runs the numbers at realistic monthly sales volumes, so you can decide on cost, not marketing.

What Do Square POS and Shopify POS Each Include?

Square POS grew out of in-person payments. Its free Point of Sale app runs on a tablet or phone, takes card payments through Square’s own payment processing, and tracks basic inventory and sales reports. Paid tiers add team permissions, advanced inventory, and loyalty tools. Because Square is its own payment processor, you cannot plug in a cheaper card processor — the card rate is part of the package.

Shopify POS grew out of online stores. It has two tiers: POS Lite, included with any Shopify plan, which covers basic in-person selling from your existing online catalogue; and POS Pro, a paid add-on per location, which adds staff permissions, smart inventory, and omnichannel features like buy-online-pickup-in-store. Your in-person card rate depends on which Shopify plan you are on.

The practical difference: Square is a counter system that can sell online; Shopify is an online store system that can sell at a counter. That origin shapes everything below.

If you have not settled your shortlist yet, our guide to choosing a POS system for a small retail shop walks through the same decision step by step.

How Do Square and Shopify POS Fees Compare at Real Sales Volumes?

Most comparisons quote a headline card rate without multiplying it by your sales. Do the maths at your volume, because a lower rate only helps once it outweighs the monthly fee.

Use these in-person card rates, checked 15 Nov 2026 on the vendors’ own pricing pages (rates vary by plan and region, and both providers change them — always confirm the current rate before signing): Square’s free plan charges 2.6% plus 15¢ per in-person transaction, with no monthly software fee. Shopify’s in-person rate depends on your plan: 2.6% plus 10¢ on Basic ($29 a month when billed yearly, $39 month to month), 2.5% plus 10¢ on Grow ($79 a month billed yearly), and 2.4% plus 10¢ on Advanced ($299 a month billed yearly). POS Pro, if you need it, is a separate $89 a month per location.

The table below turns those rates into a monthly bill at three realistic volumes. The totals are the percentage fee plus the monthly plan fee; the 15¢ (Square) or 10¢ (Shopify) charge on each sale is not included, because it depends on how many sales you take.

Now run three shops through that maths, ignoring the fixed per-transaction cents for clarity:

Monthly card sales (in person)Square Free — 2.6% + 15¢, $0 a monthShopify Basic — 2.6% + 10¢, $29 a month*Shopify Grow — 2.5% + 10¢, $79 a month*
$5,000$130$159$204
$10,000$260$289$329
$25,000$650$679$704

Rates checked 15 Nov 2026 at squareup.com/us/en/pricing and shopify.com/pricing. Shopify plan prices are the pay-yearly prices; paying month to month costs $39 on Basic and $105 on Grow. Adding POS Pro costs another $89 a month per location.

A market-stall-sized shop: $10,000 a month in card sales. Square at 2.6% costs about $260 a month, with no software fee. Shopify Basic at the same 2.6% plus $29 for the plan costs about $289 a month, and Grow at 2.5% plus $79 costs about $329 — and more if you add POS Pro. At this size, Square is cheaper and simpler, and you are not paying for an online store you barely use.

A neighbourhood shop: $25,000 a month in card sales. Square at 2.6% costs about $650 a month. Shopify Basic costs about $679 a month, and Grow about $704. Square is still cheaper, and if this shop already runs a Shopify online store, the extra cost buys one inventory system instead of two, which may be worth more than the $29 difference.

A busy two-till shop: $50,000 a month in card sales. Square at 2.6% costs about $1,300 a month. Shopify Basic costs about $1,329 a month, Grow also about $1,329, and Advanced about $1,499 — so Square is still the cheapest on card fees alone at this size. At this volume, the card-rate difference finally matters, and a shop that also sells online will usually come out ahead on Shopify once you count the time saved by not reconciling two stock systems.

The lesson of this square vs shopify pos for small business comparison: on in-person card fees alone, Square’s free plan is the cheapest at every volume in this table, because Shopify Basic charges the same 2.6% as Square and then adds a monthly fee, while Grow’s slightly lower 2.5% rate saves only $10 per $10,000 of sales — far less than its $79 fee. Shopify only starts to win on card fees when monthly card sales pass roughly $79,000, where Grow’s lower rate finally covers its fee. Below that, choose Shopify for its online store and single inventory, not for cheaper card processing.

Watch for two fee traps on both sides. First, “free” plans earn their money through the card rate — but a paid plan only wins when its lower rate outweighs its monthly fee. Shopify Advanced charges 2.4% instead of 2.6%, saving 0.2%, yet costs $299 a month, so it only beats Square’s free plan once monthly card sales pass roughly $149,500. Second, both providers add fees outside the headline rate: refund handling, chargebacks, and optional add-ons like loyalty and gift cards all carry their own charges. Ask each provider for a worked total at your volume, in writing, before you commit.

What Does the Hardware Really Cost — and What Locks You In?

Square’s hardware is famously easy to start with: a free or cheap card reader, a tablet stand, and a receipt printer, with complete counter kits in the few-hundred-dollar range. The catch is lock-in. Square readers and stands work only with Square. If you leave Square, the hardware becomes scrap, and you buy a new kit. Price that replacement into your decision: a full counter kit replaced once costs roughly what a year of a rival’s monthly fee would.

Shopify’s hardware carries the same lock-in — its readers and stands work only with Shopify POS. But Shopify’s bigger lock-in is not the reader; it is your online store. If your website, product catalogue, customer records, and order history all live in Shopify, moving your POS means moving your store too, or running two systems that drift out of sync.

The table below lists the headline hardware for one till, at the prices on the vendors’ own stores on 15 Nov 2026. Stands, printers, cash drawers, and extra readers are on top of these prices, so budget for the full counter, not just the reader.

DeviceWhat it isPriceGood to know
Square Reader (contactless and chip)Pocket card reader that pairs with a phone or tablet$59The magstripe reader is free for your first one
Square TerminalAll-in-one counter terminal with a built-in receipt printer$299Or $27 a month over 12 months
Square Register (2nd generation)Two-screen counter system with a customer display$899Or $44 a month over 24 months
Shopify POS TerminalCountertop payment terminal with a customer display, dock included$349Payment terminal only — run the POS app on a tablet
Verifone Victa Mobile (replaces Shopify POS Go)Handheld all-in-one POS with a barcode scanner$399; $449 with dockShopify POS Go is deprecated and stops working as a mobile POS on 26 May 2027

Prices checked 15 Nov 2026 at squareup.com/us/en/hardware and hardware.shopify.com. Shopify’s hardware store also lists financing from $31.50 a month for the POS Terminal.

Count the hardware and the monthly plan together in your IT budget for a small business before you buy.

Before you sign with either provider, run this lock-in check: can you export your full product catalogue, customer list, and at least a year of sales history as a CSV file you can actually import elsewhere? Both providers offer exports, but test the export before you depend on it — a PDF report is not an export. And check the contract: both are generally month-to-month with no long-term lock-in on software, which is a genuine advantage over older till vendors. Hardware, not contracts, is where you get stuck.

A concrete example: a small gift shop started on Square with a $300 counter kit, then built a Shopify online store a year later and ran both systems for six months. Staff updated stock twice, oversold twice, and spent Friday afternoons reconciling the two. The shop eventually moved its counter to Shopify POS — paying for new readers and stands — because one stock system was worth more than the sunk hardware cost. The mistake was not the first choice; it was running two systems for six months instead of deciding once.

Which POS Is Better for a Shop That Also Sells Online?

If online sales are more than about a third of your revenue, Shopify POS is usually the better buy despite the subscription, for one reason: single inventory. A sale online reduces counter stock automatically, a return in-store updates the online record, and a customer who buys in both places has one history. That is the feature that saves real staff hours every week.

If online sales are an occasional extra — a few orders a month through a simple website — Square is usually the better buy. Its free plan keeps counter costs low, and you are not paying a monthly subscription for an online platform you barely use.

There is a middle case worth naming: shops that sell mainly in-store but plan to grow online. Starting on Square is fine, but budget the switch. When online sales pass roughly a third of revenue, plan a quiet-season move to Shopify POS rather than limping along with two systems. Never switch POS in December or the week before a sale event.

Shopify Online Store vs Square Online: Which Grows Better?

Shopify’s online store is the stronger place to grow. Every Shopify plan includes a full online store that shares stock, customers, and orders with the POS, so a sale online updates the shop floor straight away. Online card rates are 2.9% plus 30¢ on Basic, 2.7% plus 30¢ on Grow, and 2.5% plus 30¢ on Advanced — the same plans you already pay for in store, with no separate store subscription.

Square Online is a simpler storefront, and it suits a shop where online is a small extra: a few orders a month, a small catalogue, and no need for advanced discounts or apps. On Square’s free plan, online sales cost 3.3% plus 30¢; on Plus and Premium, 2.9% plus 30¢. It works, but a large catalogue, heavy discounting, or a content plan will outgrow it faster than Shopify’s store.

Bottom line: if online sales are already a third of your revenue, or you expect them to be within a year, Shopify’s store is the safer growth path. If online will stay a sideline, Square Online keeps everything in one place for less money.

A POS is only one layer of the software a shop runs on, so see how to build a startup tech stack on a budget if you are pricing the rest of it too.

A Two-Week Test Before You Commit

Do not choose from pricing pages when weighing square vs shopify pos for small business. Run both free trials through this two-week test. Week 1, the counter test: set up a trial till with your real products, including the awkward ones — sale items, weighed goods, split payments, and a refund. Hand it to your least tech-confident staff member and note where they get stuck. Time a five-item sale on each system. Week 2, the back-office test: check stock after a day of test sales, run the daily takings report, and try exporting your product list as a CSV. Call support once with a real question and note how long a human takes to answer. Then calculate the total monthly cost at your actual card volume using the method above, and pick the cheaper total — unless single inventory saves you more staff hours than the price gap.

FAQ

Is Square POS really free for a small shop?

The Square Point of Sale app itself is free, but Square earns from the card rate on every sale — 2.6% plus 15¢ per in-person transaction — plus paid hardware and optional add-ons. For a shop doing under about $20,000 a month in card sales, that usually still works out cheaper than a subscription POS. Always calculate the total monthly cost at your volume, not the software price alone.

Do I need Shopify POS Pro, or is POS Lite enough?

POS Lite, included with any Shopify plan, covers basic in-person selling from your online catalogue and suits a single till with simple needs. You need POS Pro if you want staff roles and permissions, smart inventory across locations, or omnichannel features like buy-online-pickup-in-store. Start on Lite and upgrade only when a specific feature earns its roughly $89 a month per location.

Can I switch from Square to Shopify POS later?

Yes, but budget for new card readers and stands, because Square hardware does not work with Shopify POS, and allow a quiet week to migrate and test your product catalogue and stock counts. Export your catalogue, customers, and sales history as CSV files before you cancel anything, and run both systems in parallel for a few trading days before the old till goes.

Which is better for a shop with no online store?

Square, in most cases. Without an online store to unify, Shopify’s main advantage disappears, and you would be paying a monthly subscription for a platform you barely use. Square’s free plan, simple setup, and month-to-month terms fit a counter-only shop best — until online sales grow to roughly a third of revenue, when the single-inventory case for Shopify starts to win.


0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *